Customs Broker vs Self-Clearance in Canada: When Each Makes Sense

At some point in the customs process, many people ask the same question:

“Do I really need a customs broker, or can I clear this myself?”

Sometimes this question comes before shipping. More often, it comes after something has gone wrong.

This post explains the difference between using a customs broker and self-clearing in Canada, based on how these situations actually play out with our customers.

What Self-Clearance Means in Canada

Self-clearance means you, as the importer, deal directly with CBSA to clear your shipment. You are responsible for:

• Providing accurate information
• Submitting required documents
• Responding to CBSA questions
• Paying duties and taxes
• Correcting issues if something doesn’t line up

Self-clearance is allowed in Canada, but it assumes you understand the process and have time to manage it.

What a Customs Broker Does

A customs broker acts on your behalf to:

• Prepare and submit customs declarations
• Ensure documents meet CBSA requirements
• Respond to CBSA questions
• Handle duty and tax calculations
• Resolve issues that arise during clearance

Importantly, a broker does not make or change CBSA’s rules. They help ensure the shipment is presented in a way that CBSA can process efficiently.

Why This Question Comes Up So Often

Based on our experience with customers, this question usually appears when:

• A shipment is delayed
• CBSA asks for clarification
• Responsibility is unclear
• Costs are higher than expected

People often start by assuming:

“I’ll just clear it myself to save money.”

Then they call when:

“I’m not sure what CBSA wants.”

When Self-Clearance Can Make Sense

Self-clearance may be reasonable when:

• The shipment is simple
• The goods are of low value
• The documentation is straightforward
• You are comfortable dealing directly with CBSA
• Timing is not critical

In these cases, self-clearance can work smoothly if everything is prepared correctly upfront.

When a Customs Broker Usually Makes Sense

A broker is often the better option when:

• The shipment is commercial
• The value is high
• The goods are regulated
• Timing matters
• There are documentation or valuation questions
• The shipment is already delayed

Many customer inquiries involve people who tried to self-clear and then say:

“I didn’t realize how involved this would be.”

Can You Switch From Self-Clearance to a Broker?

Yes, but it often happens after delays have already started. Switching mid-process can:

• Add time
• Require correcting earlier submissions
• Trigger reassessment by CBSA

This is why people often say:

“I wish I had known this earlier.”

Deciding upfront usually avoids these complications.

Does Using a Broker Guarantee Faster Clearance?

No, but it often reduces preventable delays. A broker cannot:

• Override CBSA decisions
• Skip required checks
• Eliminate duties or taxes

What they can do is:

• Submit complete, clear information
• Anticipate common issues
• Respond quickly when CBSA asks questions

That difference matters when timing is tight.

Who Is Responsible Either Way?

This is a critical point. Whether you self-clear or use a broker:

• The importer of record remains legally responsible for the shipment, including classification, valuation, origin, and admissibility
• CBSA holds the importer accountable for duties, taxes, and penalties, even if a broker prepared the entry on your behalf
• Using a broker does not transfer liability. It reduces operational risk, but compliance responsibility stays with the importer
• Under CARM, importers must be properly registered with an active BN/RM account and must delegate authority to their broker in the CARM Client Portal, or the broker may not be able to clear shipments
• If information provided to the broker is incomplete or inaccurate, CBSA may reassess the shipment later, issue adjustments, or apply AMPS penalties
• Recordkeeping obligations still apply either way. Importers must retain supporting documentation in case CBSA audits the shipment after release

In other words, a broker helps manage the process, but the importer remains responsible for getting it right

The Most Important Takeaway

The choice between a customs broker and self-clearance is not about right or wrong.

It’s about:

• Complexity
• Risk
• Time
• Your familiarity with the process

Self-clearance can work for simple cases. A customs broker often makes sense when the situation is more complex or when delays would be costly.

Whether you self-clear or use a broker, knowing the cost upfront changes everything.

Use the BorderBuddy duty & tax calculator to get a clearer picture before choosing your path. BorderBuddy’s calculator also uses AI to help classify goods under the correct HS (Harmonized System) code, a key factor in determining the duty rate applied to an import.

What to Read Next

People deciding between self-clearance and a broker often ask next:

• What documents are required for customs clearance in Canada?
• What happens when a shipment is held at customs?
• Who is responsible for clearing a shipment into Canada? (coming soon)
• How to clear goods through CBSA? (coming soon)

Still Need Help With Your Import?

If you still didn’t find what you were looking for, BorderBuddy is here to help.

• Call us at 1 (877) 409-8163
• Or email us anytime at service@borderbuddy.com

Our team can help you get clear answers and avoid delays at the border.

‍